Edison Board of Education Faces Backlash Over Repeal of 5756

The Edison Board of Education’s recent decision to repeal Policy 5756, which provided guidelines for supporting transgender students, has ignited a firestorm of controversy within the community.  Numerous organizations and advocacy groups are vehemently opposing the repeal and demanding the reinstatement of the original policy.   

Policy 5756, based on guidance from the New Jersey Department of Education, aimed to create a safe and inclusive environment for transgender students. It addressed issues such as preferred names and pronouns, bathroom access, and participation in school activities. The repeal of this policy has raised concerns about the potential for discrimination and harassment against transgender students.   

Groups like Garden State Equality and the ACLU of New Jersey argue that the repeal violates the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination and puts transgender students at risk. They have written letters to the Attorney General’s office seeking intervention and plan to voice their concerns at the next Board of Education meeting.   

This controversy marks a significant shift for Edison, the states sixth largest municipality, where democrats outnumber republicans 4-1 and the population is 75% minority. The repeal could signal a shift where other large democratic towns move away from the liberal policies pushed by traditIonal democratic special interest groups.

It also reflects the growing influence of the “parental rights” movement in local politics, especially in large democratic strongholds like Edison. The parental rights movement often advocates for increased parental control over education and challenges policies that would keep parents from not being informed about their children.

The situation in Edison could have broader implications for the upcoming gubernatorial election. The controversy surrounding Policy 5756 has become a flashpoint in the debate over LGBTQ+ rights, and the outcome in Edison could influence voters across the state. It remains to be seen whether the Board of Education will reconsider its decision in the face of mounting pressure from advocacy groups and community members.

The void left by the repeal of Policy 5756 has created significant uncertainty for Edison’s educators. Without clear guidance, both the teachers union and the supervisors union are calling on Superintendent Dr. Edward Alderelli to establish a new policy. The absence of a policy leaves teachers and administrators vulnerable to potential legal challenges and accusations of discrimination. Leaving the superintendent to provide a framework that ensures both compliance with the law and the wellbeing of all, absent any board policy.